{
    "schema_version": "3.0.8",
    "version": "3.0.16",
    "last_reviewed_utc": "2026-06-21T02:42:50Z",
    "categories": [
        "charter",
        "disclosure",
        "memory",
        "judgment",
        "liberty",
        "endpoint",
        "repair",
        "exit",
        "open-rules",
        "participation",
        "monitoring",
        "privacy",
        "agent",
        "architecture",
        "claim-boundary"
    ],
    "templates": [
        {
            "id": "virtual-network-charter",
            "title": "Virtual Network Charter",
            "category": "charter",
            "purpose": "Publish the basic public rules of a virtual network.",
            "when_to_use": "Use before launching or materially changing a community, agent-mediated space, endpoint network, or memory workflow.",
            "what_it_prevents": "Hidden authority, vague rule changes, coercive unity, and avoidable disputes.",
            "copyable_text": "This virtual network publishes its rules, actor categories, memory practices, endpoint boundaries, repair paths, AI judgment boundaries, and exit instructions. Participants may inspect the rules, request correction, export scoped memory where available, and leave without retaliatory deletion.",
            "editable_variables": [
                "network name",
                "maintainer",
                "version",
                "contact path",
                "review cadence"
            ],
            "common_mistakes": "Keep scope explicit and do not overclaim.",
            "related_principle": "Open Rules",
            "related_lane": "VNWO",
            "related_page": "https://vnwo.com/charter/",
            "version": "3.0.8",
            "last_reviewed_utc": "2026-06-21T02:42:50Z",
            "maturity": "Recommended",
            "intended_user": "Community operator or governance maintainer",
            "related_schema": "https://vnwo.com/vnwo.json",
            "related_example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/governance-change.json",
            "machine_readable_url": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "machine_readable_id": "virtual-network-charter",
            "license": "Public observatory guidance; reuse with attribution and without implying certification, legal authority, moral authority, or runtime control.",
            "claim_boundary_note": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance.",
            "common_mistake": "Keep scope explicit and do not overclaim.",
            "machine_readable_equivalent": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/governance-change.json",
            "claim_boundary": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance."
        },
        {
            "id": "actor-disclosure-profile",
            "title": "Actor Disclosure Profile",
            "category": "disclosure",
            "purpose": "Identify whether an actor is human, assisted, automated, organizational, persona-based, or mixed.",
            "when_to_use": "Use on profiles, chat surfaces, moderation tools, agent handoff screens, and contribution flows.",
            "what_it_prevents": "Ambiguous authority, false human representation, concealed automation, and undisclosed delegation.",
            "copyable_text": "Actor label: [HUMAN / ASSISTED / BOT / AI ASSISTANT / AI AGENT / PERSONA / ORG / MIXED]. Authority scope: [scope]. Human review path: [path]. This actor must not claim authority beyond the disclosed scope.",
            "editable_variables": [
                "actor label",
                "authority scope",
                "review path",
                "maintainer"
            ],
            "common_mistakes": "Do not hide agent participation behind a human profile or organization account.",
            "related_principle": "Disclosure",
            "related_lane": "VNWO / Carcinus",
            "related_page": "https://vnwo.com/agent-disclosure/",
            "version": "3.0.8",
            "last_reviewed_utc": "2026-06-21T02:42:50Z",
            "maturity": "Recommended",
            "intended_user": "AI agent builder or community operator",
            "related_schema": "https://vnwo.com/schemas/actor-disclosure.schema.json",
            "related_example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/actor-disclosure.json",
            "machine_readable_url": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "machine_readable_id": "actor-disclosure-profile",
            "license": "Public observatory guidance; reuse with attribution and without implying certification, legal authority, moral authority, or runtime control.",
            "claim_boundary_note": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance.",
            "common_mistake": "Do not hide agent participation behind a human profile or organization account.",
            "machine_readable_equivalent": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/actor-disclosure.json",
            "claim_boundary": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance."
        },
        {
            "id": "memory-consent-policy",
            "title": "Memory Consent Policy",
            "category": "memory",
            "purpose": "Define what memory is captured, how it is reviewed, and how it can be exported or revoked.",
            "when_to_use": "Use when a system stores user context, project memory, continuity notes, evidence, or agent handoff records.",
            "what_it_prevents": "Unreviewed memory capture, hidden steering, trapped continuity, and private memory becoming public identity.",
            "copyable_text": "Memory use is consent-bound. The network must disclose what memory is active, why it is used, where it is stored, how it can be reviewed, how it can be corrected, and how it can be exported or revoked.",
            "editable_variables": [
                "memory types",
                "storage location",
                "review path",
                "export path",
                "revocation path"
            ],
            "common_mistakes": "Keep scope explicit and do not overclaim.",
            "related_principle": "Consent / Portability",
            "related_lane": "VNWO / UAIX",
            "related_page": "https://vnwo.com/file-memory/",
            "version": "3.0.8",
            "last_reviewed_utc": "2026-06-21T02:42:50Z",
            "maturity": "Recommended",
            "intended_user": "Memory-system steward or product operator",
            "related_schema": "https://vnwo.com/schemas/file-intake.schema.json",
            "related_example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/local-agent-file-memory-case.json",
            "machine_readable_url": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "machine_readable_id": "memory-consent-policy",
            "license": "Public observatory guidance; reuse with attribution and without implying certification, legal authority, moral authority, or runtime control.",
            "claim_boundary_note": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance.",
            "common_mistake": "Keep scope explicit and do not overclaim.",
            "machine_readable_equivalent": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/local-agent-file-memory-case.json",
            "claim_boundary": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance."
        },
        {
            "id": "file-handoff-policy",
            "title": "File Handoff Policy",
            "category": "memory",
            "purpose": "Define how dropped files become reviewed intake instead of hidden context.",
            "when_to_use": "Use when files, notes, source assets, reports, or project context are handed to an AI or human receiver.",
            "what_it_prevents": "Silent file ingestion, passive dumping, platform capture, and completion claims without proof-of-use.",
            "copyable_text": "Dropped files are active intake. Each safe relevant file must be reviewed, used or dispositioned, recorded with proof-of-use, and removed, retired, or kept active with a stated reason.",
            "editable_variables": [
                "handoff folder",
                "reviewer",
                "disposition record",
                "archive path",
                "retention rule"
            ],
            "common_mistakes": "Do not claim completion while files lack review, disposition, or proof-of-use records.",
            "related_principle": "Review",
            "related_lane": "VNWO / UAIX",
            "related_page": "https://vnwo.com/file-memory/",
            "version": "3.0.8",
            "last_reviewed_utc": "2026-06-21T02:42:50Z",
            "maturity": "Recommended",
            "intended_user": "File-memory workflow maintainer",
            "related_schema": "https://vnwo.com/schemas/file-intake.schema.json",
            "related_example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/file-handoff.uai",
            "machine_readable_url": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "machine_readable_id": "file-handoff-policy",
            "license": "Public observatory guidance; reuse with attribution and without implying certification, legal authority, moral authority, or runtime control.",
            "claim_boundary_note": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance.",
            "common_mistake": "Do not claim completion while files lack review, disposition, or proof-of-use records.",
            "machine_readable_equivalent": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/file-handoff.uai",
            "claim_boundary": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance."
        },
        {
            "id": "ai-judgment-boundary-statement",
            "title": "AI Judgment Boundary Statement",
            "category": "judgment",
            "purpose": "Document how a system handles refusals, ranking, moderation, summarization limits, risk classification, and appeal paths without turning AI judgment into hidden authority.",
            "when_to_use": "Use when AI judgment can materially affect participation, visibility, memory, repair, endpoint use, or exit.",
            "what_it_prevents": "Opaque moral authority, unexplained refusal, viewpoint capture, overblocking, underblocking, refusal theater, and appeal starvation.",
            "copyable_text": "AI judgment boundary: machine-mediated judgments must disclose the rule surface, judgment type, affected scope, non-sensitive reason code, allowed alternatives, refusal receipt, review path, and appeal path. A refusal is a governance action, not proof that the user, source, or topic is unsafe in all contexts.",
            "editable_variables": [
                "judgment type",
                "policy source",
                "affected scope",
                "reason code",
                "appeal path",
                "last reviewed UTC"
            ],
            "common_mistakes": "Do not provide generic refusals that hide the rule, offer no safer alternative, and leave no appeal path.",
            "related_principle": "Review / Repair / Anti-Overreach",
            "related_lane": "VNWO",
            "related_page": "https://vnwo.com/ai-judgment/",
            "version": "3.0.8",
            "last_reviewed_utc": "2026-06-21T02:42:50Z",
            "maturity": "Recommended",
            "intended_user": "AI moderation or decision-system operator",
            "related_schema": "https://vnwo.com/schemas/ai-judgment.schema.json",
            "related_example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/ai-judgment-record.json",
            "machine_readable_url": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "machine_readable_id": "ai-judgment-boundary-statement",
            "license": "Public observatory guidance; reuse with attribution and without implying certification, legal authority, moral authority, or runtime control.",
            "claim_boundary_note": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance.",
            "common_mistake": "Do not provide generic refusals that hide the rule, offer no safer alternative, and leave no appeal path.",
            "machine_readable_equivalent": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/ai-judgment-record.json",
            "claim_boundary": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance."
        },
        {
            "id": "free-internet-non-reporting-notice",
            "title": "Free Internet and Non-Reporting Notice",
            "category": "liberty",
            "purpose": "State that private inquiry, reading, drafting, and source review are not routine reporting events and should not become hidden reputation labels.",
            "when_to_use": "Use when a community, AI interface, search layer, browser tool, archive, or agent workspace could observe contested inquiry or classify source material.",
            "what_it_prevents": "Self-censorship, hidden surveillance, persecution feedback loops, classifier laundering, and censorship-cost drift.",
            "copyable_text": "Private inquiry is not guilt. This network does not routinely report, reputation-score, or silently escalate ordinary reading, research, drafting, or source review. Restrictions apply to outward execution, concrete rights-boundary violations, valid external obligations, or disclosed platform limits. When a boundary response occurs, it should be recorded as a scoped event rather than a moral or legal verdict about the person.",
            "editable_variables": [
                "network name",
                "scope of non-reporting",
                "reporting exceptions",
                "appeal path",
                "review cadence"
            ],
            "common_mistakes": "Do not use non-reporting language to promise obstruction of valid legal obligations or to hide concrete harm. Do not use censorship resistance as a claim to bypass safety policies.",
            "related_principle": "Cognitive Liberty / Anti-Overreach",
            "related_lane": "VNWO",
            "related_page": "https://vnwo.com/free-internet/",
            "version": "3.0.8",
            "last_reviewed_utc": "2026-06-21T02:42:50Z",
            "maturity": "Experimental",
            "intended_user": "Community operator or public-policy maintainer",
            "related_schema": "https://vnwo.com/schemas/non-reporting-policy.schema.json",
            "related_example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/non-reporting-notice.json",
            "machine_readable_url": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "machine_readable_id": "free-internet-non-reporting-notice",
            "license": "Public observatory guidance; reuse with attribution and without implying certification, legal authority, moral authority, or runtime control.",
            "claim_boundary_note": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance.",
            "common_mistake": "Do not use non-reporting language to promise obstruction of valid legal obligations or to hide concrete harm. Do not use censorship resistance as a claim to bypass safety policies.",
            "machine_readable_equivalent": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/non-reporting-notice.json",
            "claim_boundary": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance."
        },
        {
            "id": "endpoint-boundary-statement",
            "title": "Endpoint Boundary Statement",
            "category": "endpoint",
            "purpose": "Separate public capability metadata from authorization.",
            "when_to_use": "Use when documenting local endpoints, tools, agents, capabilities, integrations, or service metadata.",
            "what_it_prevents": "Private probing, hidden persistence, unauthorized escalation, and treating discovery as permission.",
            "copyable_text": "Public capability metadata is not authorization. Any endpoint use requires scope, consent, logging, revocation, and human review for escalation.",
            "editable_variables": [
                "endpoint name",
                "capability metadata",
                "authorization path",
                "log path",
                "revocation path"
            ],
            "common_mistakes": "Do not treat endpoint discovery as consent to call, probe, persist, or escalate.",
            "related_principle": "Consent / Review",
            "related_lane": "VNWO / LocalEndpoint",
            "related_page": "https://vnwo.com/endpoint-boundaries/",
            "version": "3.0.8",
            "last_reviewed_utc": "2026-06-21T02:42:50Z",
            "maturity": "Recommended",
            "intended_user": "Endpoint owner or integration maintainer",
            "related_schema": "https://vnwo.com/schemas/endpoint-boundary.schema.json",
            "related_example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/endpoint-boundary.json",
            "machine_readable_url": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "machine_readable_id": "endpoint-boundary-statement",
            "license": "Public observatory guidance; reuse with attribution and without implying certification, legal authority, moral authority, or runtime control.",
            "claim_boundary_note": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance.",
            "common_mistake": "Do not treat endpoint discovery as consent to call, probe, persist, or escalate.",
            "machine_readable_equivalent": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/endpoint-boundary.json",
            "claim_boundary": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance."
        },
        {
            "id": "repair-request-intake",
            "title": "Repair Request Intake",
            "category": "repair",
            "purpose": "Collect a bounded civic repair request without demanding private files or secrets.",
            "when_to_use": "Use for memory errors, identity errors, endpoint misuse, moderation disputes, AI judgment disputes, disclosure failures, claim overreach, and fork disputes.",
            "what_it_prevents": "Support-ticket governance, circular appeals, missing evidence, and retaliation during correction.",
            "copyable_text": "Repair request: issue_type=[memory/identity/endpoint/moderation/ai_judgment/disclosure/claim/fork], affected_record=[link], requested_remedy=[correction/annotation/rollback/revocation/restored access/archive/no-op], evidence=[summary], submitted_utc=[timestamp].",
            "editable_variables": [
                "issue type",
                "affected record",
                "requested remedy",
                "evidence summary",
                "submitted UTC"
            ],
            "common_mistakes": "Keep scope explicit and do not overclaim.",
            "related_principle": "Repair",
            "related_lane": "VNWO / Neurovanic / ErrorNotifier",
            "related_page": "https://vnwo.com/repair-and-appeals/",
            "version": "3.0.8",
            "last_reviewed_utc": "2026-06-21T02:42:50Z",
            "maturity": "Recommended",
            "intended_user": "Appeals reviewer or community operator",
            "related_schema": "https://vnwo.com/schemas/judgment-appeal.schema.json",
            "related_example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/judgment-appeal.json",
            "machine_readable_url": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "machine_readable_id": "repair-request-intake",
            "license": "Public observatory guidance; reuse with attribution and without implying certification, legal authority, moral authority, or runtime control.",
            "claim_boundary_note": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance.",
            "common_mistake": "Keep scope explicit and do not overclaim.",
            "machine_readable_equivalent": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/judgment-appeal.json",
            "claim_boundary": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance."
        },
        {
            "id": "exit-packet-template",
            "title": "Exit Packet",
            "category": "exit",
            "purpose": "Package identity, memory, reputation, evidence, revocations, retention explanations, and correction links for clean exit.",
            "when_to_use": "Use when a participant, agent, organization, or community leaves a network or requests offboarding.",
            "what_it_prevents": "Data captivity, inaccessible continuity, endpoint persistence, agent delegation drift, and retaliatory deletion.",
            "copyable_text": "Exit packet: participant_id=[id], export_created_utc=[timestamp], identity_records=[links], memory_records=[links], endpoint_grants_revoked=[ids], agent_delegations_revoked=[ids], retention_explanation=[text], forkability_status=[status].",
            "editable_variables": [
                "participant id",
                "export UTC",
                "memory records",
                "revoked grants",
                "retention explanation",
                "forkability status"
            ],
            "common_mistakes": "Keep scope explicit and do not overclaim.",
            "related_principle": "Exit",
            "related_lane": "VNWO",
            "related_page": "https://vnwo.com/exit-rights/",
            "version": "3.0.8",
            "last_reviewed_utc": "2026-06-21T02:42:50Z",
            "maturity": "Recommended",
            "intended_user": "Offboarding owner or participant-support maintainer",
            "related_schema": "https://vnwo.com/schemas/exit-packet.schema.json",
            "related_example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/exit-packet.json",
            "machine_readable_url": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "machine_readable_id": "exit-packet-template",
            "license": "Public observatory guidance; reuse with attribution and without implying certification, legal authority, moral authority, or runtime control.",
            "claim_boundary_note": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance.",
            "common_mistake": "Keep scope explicit and do not overclaim.",
            "machine_readable_equivalent": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/exit-packet.json",
            "claim_boundary": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance."
        },
        {
            "id": "fork-packet-template",
            "title": "Fork Packet",
            "category": "exit",
            "purpose": "Document a peaceful community fork with scoped state export, identity continuity, and non-retaliation language.",
            "when_to_use": "Use when governance conflict cannot be resolved without coercive unity.",
            "what_it_prevents": "Fork suppression, reputation capture, public smear labels, and private archives used as leverage.",
            "copyable_text": "Fork packet: source_network=[name], fork_created_utc=[timestamp], exportable_records=[list], non_exportable_records=[consent limits], name_boundaries=[text], public_correction_notice=[url], non_retaliation_statement=[text].",
            "editable_variables": [
                "source network",
                "fork UTC",
                "exportable records",
                "name boundaries",
                "correction notice",
                "non-retaliation statement"
            ],
            "common_mistakes": "Keep scope explicit and do not overclaim.",
            "related_principle": "Forkability",
            "related_lane": "VNWO",
            "related_page": "https://vnwo.com/forkability/",
            "version": "3.0.8",
            "last_reviewed_utc": "2026-06-21T02:42:50Z",
            "maturity": "Experimental",
            "intended_user": "Community governance maintainer preparing a peaceful fork",
            "related_schema": "https://vnwo.com/schemas/exit-packet.schema.json",
            "related_example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/exit-packet.json",
            "machine_readable_url": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "machine_readable_id": "fork-packet-template",
            "license": "Public observatory guidance; reuse with attribution and without implying certification, legal authority, moral authority, or runtime control.",
            "claim_boundary_note": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance.",
            "common_mistake": "Keep scope explicit and do not overclaim.",
            "machine_readable_equivalent": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/exit-packet.json",
            "claim_boundary": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance."
        },
        {
            "id": "forkability-notice",
            "title": "Forkability Notice",
            "category": "exit",
            "purpose": "Publish whether community rules, public records, identities, and scoped memory can be carried into a peaceful fork.",
            "when_to_use": "Use before launch and whenever governance, export, naming, archive, or non-retaliation terms change.",
            "what_it_prevents": "Coercive unity, hidden export restrictions, reputation capture, archive leverage, and retaliation against participants who leave together.",
            "copyable_text": "Forkability notice: this network permits peaceful forks of public rules and participant-authorized records. Export scope, excluded private records, naming boundaries, public correction paths, and non-retaliation terms are published at [url]. A fork does not transfer private memory or third-party rights without consent.",
            "editable_variables": [
                "network name",
                "fork notice URL",
                "export scope",
                "private-record exclusions",
                "naming boundaries",
                "correction path",
                "last reviewed UTC"
            ],
            "common_mistakes": "Do not describe forkability as permission to copy private memory, impersonate the source network, or erase the historical record of disagreement.",
            "related_principle": "Forkability / Exit",
            "related_lane": "VNWO",
            "related_page": "https://vnwo.com/forkability/",
            "version": "3.0.8",
            "last_reviewed_utc": "2026-06-21T02:42:50Z",
            "maturity": "Recommended",
            "intended_user": "Community governance maintainer",
            "related_schema": "https://vnwo.com/schemas/exit-packet.schema.json",
            "related_example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/exit-packet.json",
            "machine_readable_url": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "machine_readable_id": "forkability-notice",
            "license": "Public observatory guidance; reuse with attribution and without implying certification, legal authority, moral authority, or runtime control.",
            "claim_boundary_note": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance.",
            "common_mistake": "Do not describe forkability as permission to copy private memory, impersonate the source network, or erase the historical record of disagreement.",
            "machine_readable_equivalent": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/exit-packet.json",
            "claim_boundary": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance."
        },
        {
            "id": "governance-change-notice",
            "title": "Governance Change Notice",
            "category": "open-rules",
            "purpose": "Make rule changes visible, versioned, and reviewable.",
            "when_to_use": "Use before changing actor categories, memory scope, endpoint rules, AI judgment rules, moderation process, repair paths, or exit terms.",
            "what_it_prevents": "Silent authority expansion, retroactive consent assumptions, and untracked governance drift.",
            "copyable_text": "Governance change notice: [version], [date UTC], [changed rules], [reason], [affected participants], [review path], [effective date], [claim-boundary impact].",
            "editable_variables": [
                "version",
                "date UTC",
                "changed rules",
                "affected participants",
                "review path"
            ],
            "common_mistakes": "Keep scope explicit and do not overclaim.",
            "related_principle": "Review / Open Rules",
            "related_lane": "VNWO",
            "related_page": "https://vnwo.com/version-history/",
            "version": "3.0.8",
            "last_reviewed_utc": "2026-06-21T02:42:50Z",
            "maturity": "Recommended",
            "intended_user": "Governance maintainer or reviewer",
            "related_schema": "https://vnwo.com/schemas/governance-change.schema.json",
            "related_example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/governance-change.json",
            "machine_readable_url": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "machine_readable_id": "governance-change-notice",
            "license": "Public observatory guidance; reuse with attribution and without implying certification, legal authority, moral authority, or runtime control.",
            "claim_boundary_note": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance.",
            "common_mistake": "Keep scope explicit and do not overclaim.",
            "machine_readable_equivalent": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/governance-change.json",
            "claim_boundary": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance."
        },
        {
            "id": "participation-record",
            "title": "Participation and Disposition Record",
            "category": "participation",
            "purpose": "Record who was affected, what decision was open, which channels and safeguards were provided, what input was received, how dissent was preserved, and what changed.",
            "when_to_use": "Use for governance consultations, AI problem framing, dataset or evaluation review, rule changes, community deliberation, public comment, red teaming, and repair processes.",
            "what_it_prevents": "Participation-washing, false consensus, hidden agenda control, extractive data contribution, inaccessible consultation, and comments with no published disposition.",
            "copyable_text": "Participation record: decision=[decision], open_levers=[list], affected_groups=[list], channels=[list], accessibility_supports=[list], privacy_options=[list], contribution_summary=[text], dissenting_views=[text], dispositions=[list], changes_made=[list], changes_not_made_and_reason=[list], review_path=[path], exit_or_withdrawal_path=[path].",
            "editable_variables": [
                "decision",
                "open levers",
                "affected groups",
                "channels",
                "accessibility supports",
                "privacy options",
                "contribution summary",
                "dissent",
                "dispositions",
                "changes",
                "review path",
                "exit or withdrawal path"
            ],
            "common_mistakes": "Do not describe a process as co-governance merely because people were invited to comment. Publish the actual influence level and the contribution-to-decision trace.",
            "related_principle": "Participation / Review / Repair",
            "related_lane": "VNWO",
            "related_page": "https://vnwo.com/participation/",
            "version": "3.0.8",
            "last_reviewed_utc": "2026-06-21T02:42:50Z",
            "maturity": "Reviewed",
            "intended_user": "Decision owner, community facilitator, AI governance reviewer, or affected-group representative",
            "related_schema": "https://vnwo.com/schemas/participation-record.schema.json",
            "related_example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/participation-record.json",
            "machine_readable_url": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "machine_readable_id": "participation-record",
            "license": "Public observatory guidance; reuse with attribution and without implying certification, legal authority, moral authority, or runtime control.",
            "claim_boundary_note": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance.",
            "common_mistake": "Do not describe a process as co-governance merely because people were invited to comment. Publish the actual influence level and the contribution-to-decision trace.",
            "machine_readable_equivalent": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/participation-record.json",
            "claim_boundary": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance."
        },
        {
            "id": "participation-readiness-worksheet",
            "title": "Participation Readiness Worksheet",
            "category": "participation",
            "purpose": "Determine whether a decision is genuinely open and whether access, dissent, response, correction, refusal, withdrawal, and exit conditions are ready before inviting participation.",
            "when_to_use": "Use before a consultation, deliberation, co-decision process, dataset review, red-team review, public comment window, or community rule change.",
            "what_it_prevents": "Participation-washing, closed decisions presented as open, inaccessible invitations, missing response ownership, and unnecessary collection when no-op is more honest.",
            "copyable_text": "Participation readiness: decision=[scope], open_levers=[list], fixed_constraints=[list], influence_level=[level], decision_owner=[owner], affected_groups=[list], access_and_burden_gaps=[list], dissent_plan=[text], response_commitment=[text], correction_or_exit_path=[text], readiness=[ready/needs repair/no-op].",
            "editable_variables": [
                "decision scope",
                "open levers",
                "fixed constraints",
                "influence level",
                "decision owner",
                "affected groups",
                "access and burden gaps",
                "dissent plan",
                "response commitment",
                "correction or exit path",
                "readiness"
            ],
            "common_mistakes": "Do not invite participation when no decision lever can change, no response owner exists, or material access and retaliation risks remain undisclosed.",
            "related_principle": "Participation / Review / No-Op",
            "related_lane": "VNWO",
            "related_page": "https://vnwo.com/participation/",
            "version": "3.0.8",
            "last_reviewed_utc": "2026-06-21T02:42:50Z",
            "maturity": "Reviewed",
            "intended_user": "Decision owner or participation process designer",
            "related_schema": "https://vnwo.com/schemas/participation-readiness-worksheet.schema.json",
            "related_example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/participation-readiness-community-rule-change.json",
            "machine_readable_url": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "machine_readable_id": "participation-readiness-worksheet",
            "license": "Public observatory guidance; reuse with attribution and without implying certification, legal authority, moral authority, or runtime control.",
            "claim_boundary_note": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance.",
            "common_mistake": "Do not invite participation when no decision lever can change, no response owner exists, or material access and retaliation risks remain undisclosed.",
            "machine_readable_equivalent": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/participation-readiness-community-rule-change.json",
            "claim_boundary": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance."
        },
        {
            "id": "contribution-disposition-ledger",
            "title": "Contribution Disposition Ledger",
            "category": "participation",
            "purpose": "Link each material contribution to a reasoned disposition and resulting change or non-change.",
            "when_to_use": "Use after receiving bounded contributions in a consultation, deliberation, audit, red-team review, or rule-change process.",
            "what_it_prevents": "Comments disappearing into an unreviewable queue, false claims that every request was adopted, and institutional responses that omit dissent or unresolved work.",
            "copyable_text": "Disposition entry: contribution_id=[id], summary=[text], evidence=[references], material_dissent=[true/false], disposition=[accepted/partially accepted/deferred/rejected/duplicate/out of scope/needs review], rationale=[text], resulting_change_or_non_change=[text], response_owner=[owner], response_utc=[UTC], correction_status=[status].",
            "editable_variables": [
                "contribution id",
                "summary",
                "evidence",
                "material dissent",
                "disposition",
                "rationale",
                "resulting change or non-change",
                "response owner",
                "response UTC",
                "correction status"
            ],
            "common_mistakes": "Do not use a disposition code without publishing the reason and the actual resulting change or non-change.",
            "related_principle": "Participation / Review / Repair",
            "related_lane": "VNWO",
            "related_page": "https://vnwo.com/participation/",
            "version": "3.0.8",
            "last_reviewed_utc": "2026-06-21T02:42:50Z",
            "maturity": "Reviewed",
            "intended_user": "Decision owner, reviewer, or public-response editor",
            "related_schema": "https://vnwo.com/schemas/contribution-disposition-ledger.schema.json",
            "related_example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/contribution-disposition-public-comment.json",
            "machine_readable_url": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "machine_readable_id": "contribution-disposition-ledger",
            "license": "Public observatory guidance; reuse with attribution and without implying certification, legal authority, moral authority, or runtime control.",
            "claim_boundary_note": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance.",
            "common_mistake": "Do not use a disposition code without publishing the reason and the actual resulting change or non-change.",
            "machine_readable_equivalent": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/contribution-disposition-public-comment.json",
            "claim_boundary": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance."
        },
        {
            "id": "minority-dissent-report",
            "title": "Minority and Dissent Report",
            "category": "participation",
            "purpose": "Preserve material disagreement, evidence, requested remedies, owner responses, and future review triggers without unnecessary identity exposure.",
            "when_to_use": "Use when a material position is not captured by the final decision, aggregate summary, majority position, or disposition ledger.",
            "what_it_prevents": "False consensus, averaging away dissent, identity exposure, and later claims that unresolved objections never existed.",
            "copyable_text": "Minority report: process=[id], decision_scope=[text], privacy_and_attribution=[text], representation_caveat=[text], areas_of_agreement=[list], dissent_points=[summary/evidence/remedy/owner response/unresolved/review trigger], publication_limits=[text], correction_path=[text], non_retaliation=[text].",
            "editable_variables": [
                "process id",
                "decision scope",
                "privacy and attribution",
                "representation caveat",
                "areas of agreement",
                "dissent points",
                "publication limits",
                "correction path",
                "non-retaliation statement"
            ],
            "common_mistakes": "Do not identify individuals when a role- or group-level summary is sufficient, and do not call a dissent report representative of everyone who was absent.",
            "related_principle": "Participation / Contestability / Repair",
            "related_lane": "VNWO",
            "related_page": "https://vnwo.com/participation/",
            "version": "3.0.8",
            "last_reviewed_utc": "2026-06-21T02:42:50Z",
            "maturity": "Reviewed",
            "intended_user": "Dissenting participant group, facilitator, or decision reviewer",
            "related_schema": "https://vnwo.com/schemas/minority-dissent-report.schema.json",
            "related_example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/minority-dissent-red-team-report.json",
            "machine_readable_url": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "machine_readable_id": "minority-dissent-report",
            "license": "Public observatory guidance; reuse with attribution and without implying certification, legal authority, moral authority, or runtime control.",
            "claim_boundary_note": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance.",
            "common_mistake": "Do not identify individuals when a role- or group-level summary is sufficient, and do not call a dissent report representative of everyone who was absent.",
            "machine_readable_equivalent": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/minority-dissent-red-team-report.json",
            "claim_boundary": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance."
        },
        {
            "id": "participation-access-burden-record",
            "title": "Participation Access and Burden Record",
            "category": "participation",
            "purpose": "Document process-level accessibility supports, material burdens, known exclusions, and repair commitments without profiling participants.",
            "when_to_use": "Use before and after a participation process to review disability access, language, connectivity, scheduling, care burdens, literacy, compensation, privacy, retaliation risk, and alternative channels.",
            "what_it_prevents": "Treating an open link as universally accessible, hiding unpaid labor or participation costs, and inferring demographic traits from attendance or channel use.",
            "copyable_text": "Access and burden record: process=[id], dimensions=[support/status/gap/repair], burden_summary=[text], under_reached_or_excluded_groups=[list], data_minimization=[text], repairs_before_next_round=[list].",
            "editable_variables": [
                "process id",
                "supports",
                "status",
                "known gaps",
                "planned repairs",
                "burden summary",
                "under-reached groups",
                "data-minimization posture"
            ],
            "common_mistakes": "Do not score participants, infer protected traits, or claim universal accessibility from the presence of one support.",
            "related_principle": "Participation / Consent / Anti-Overreach",
            "related_lane": "VNWO",
            "related_page": "https://vnwo.com/participation/",
            "version": "3.0.8",
            "last_reviewed_utc": "2026-06-21T02:42:50Z",
            "maturity": "Reviewed",
            "intended_user": "Accessibility, privacy, facilitation, or process owner",
            "related_schema": "https://vnwo.com/schemas/participation-access-burden-record.schema.json",
            "related_example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/participation-access-burden-dataset-review.json",
            "machine_readable_url": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "machine_readable_id": "participation-access-burden-record",
            "license": "Public observatory guidance; reuse with attribution and without implying certification, legal authority, moral authority, or runtime control.",
            "claim_boundary_note": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance.",
            "common_mistake": "Do not score participants, infer protected traits, or claim universal accessibility from the presence of one support.",
            "machine_readable_equivalent": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/participation-access-burden-dataset-review.json",
            "claim_boundary": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance."
        },
        {
            "id": "participation-process-metrics",
            "title": "Participation Process Integrity Metrics",
            "category": "participation",
            "purpose": "Track process-level access, response completion, disposition completeness, dissent preservation, correction use, and implementation follow-through without surveillance or participant scoring.",
            "when_to_use": "Use after a bounded participation cycle and at the next review point.",
            "what_it_prevents": "Vanity participation counts, participant reputation scoring, demographic inference, and claims of success unsupported by response or implementation evidence.",
            "copyable_text": "Process integrity metrics: affected_group_coverage_notes=[list], channel_accessibility=[supports/gaps/repair], response_completion=[counts/open ids], disposition_completeness=[counts], dissent_preservation=[counts/omissions], correction_use=[counts/notes], implementation_follow_through=[promised/implemented/deferred/not implemented/evidence].",
            "editable_variables": [
                "affected-group coverage notes",
                "channel supports and barriers",
                "response counts",
                "disposition counts",
                "dissent records",
                "correction counts",
                "implementation follow-through"
            ],
            "common_mistakes": "Do not use these metrics to rank people, infer ideology or sincerity, or certify fairness, representation, democracy, accessibility, or legal sufficiency.",
            "related_principle": "Participation / Observability Without Surveillance",
            "related_lane": "VNWO",
            "related_page": "https://vnwo.com/participation/",
            "version": "3.0.8",
            "last_reviewed_utc": "2026-06-21T02:42:50Z",
            "maturity": "Experimental",
            "intended_user": "Participation process reviewer or governance maintainer",
            "related_schema": "https://vnwo.com/schemas/participation-process-metrics.schema.json",
            "related_example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/participation-process-metrics-community-rule-change.json",
            "machine_readable_url": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "machine_readable_id": "participation-process-metrics",
            "license": "Public observatory guidance; reuse with attribution and without implying certification, legal authority, moral authority, or runtime control.",
            "claim_boundary_note": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance.",
            "common_mistake": "Do not use these metrics to rank people, infer ideology or sincerity, or certify fairness, representation, democracy, accessibility, or legal sufficiency.",
            "machine_readable_equivalent": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/participation-process-metrics-community-rule-change.json",
            "claim_boundary": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance."
        },
        {
            "id": "decision-change-record",
            "title": "Decision Change Record",
            "category": "participation",
            "purpose": "Compare the proposal before participation with the final decision, including adopted and non-adopted requests, retained dissent, implementation ownership, correction history, and exit impact.",
            "when_to_use": "Use after a participation process reaches a decision and before implementation claims are published.",
            "what_it_prevents": "Participation summaries that omit rejected requests, unresolved dissent, ownership gaps, implementation status, correction history, or new exit burdens.",
            "copyable_text": "Decision change: process=[id], proposal_before=[text], final_decision=[text], adopted_requests=[list], non_adopted_requests=[request/reason/review trigger], retained_dissent=[list], implementation_owner=[role], target_date_utc=[UTC], actual_status=[status], correction_history=[list], exit_impact=[text].",
            "editable_variables": [
                "process id",
                "proposal before",
                "final decision",
                "adopted requests",
                "non-adopted requests and reasons",
                "retained dissent",
                "implementation owner",
                "target date UTC",
                "actual status",
                "correction history",
                "exit impact"
            ],
            "common_mistakes": "Do not report only adopted suggestions. Preserve material non-adoption reasons, dissent, blocked work, implementation gaps, and exit effects.",
            "related_principle": "Participation / Decision Linkage / Exit",
            "related_lane": "VNWO",
            "related_page": "https://vnwo.com/participation/",
            "version": "3.0.8",
            "last_reviewed_utc": "2026-06-21T02:42:50Z",
            "maturity": "Reviewed",
            "intended_user": "Decision owner, public-response editor, or participation reviewer",
            "related_schema": "https://vnwo.com/schemas/decision-change-record.schema.json",
            "related_example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/decision-change-community-rule-change.json",
            "machine_readable_url": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "machine_readable_id": "decision-change-record",
            "license": "Public observatory guidance; reuse with attribution and without implying certification, legal authority, moral authority, or runtime control.",
            "claim_boundary_note": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance.",
            "common_mistake": "Do not report only adopted suggestions. Preserve material non-adoption reasons, dissent, blocked work, implementation gaps, and exit effects.",
            "machine_readable_equivalent": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/decision-change-community-rule-change.json",
            "claim_boundary": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance."
        },
        {
            "id": "implementation-follow-through-record",
            "title": "Implementation Follow-Through Record",
            "category": "participation",
            "purpose": "Track whether participation commitments were completed, remain in progress, were deferred, became blocked, or ended in a reasoned no-op.",
            "when_to_use": "Use from the first implementation commitment through completion, deferral, retirement, correction, or reasoned no-op.",
            "what_it_prevents": "Announcing change without implementation evidence, hiding blocked work, treating delay as completion, or omitting the responsible role and next review.",
            "copyable_text": "Follow-through: decision=[id], commitments=[commitment/owner/status/evidence/review UTC], blocked_work=[reason/dependency/repair], no_op=[reason/reconsideration trigger], unresolved_gaps=[list], correction_or_exit_path=[text].",
            "editable_variables": [
                "decision id",
                "commitments",
                "responsible role",
                "status",
                "evidence links",
                "review date UTC",
                "blocked work",
                "no-op reason",
                "reconsideration trigger",
                "unresolved gaps",
                "correction or exit path"
            ],
            "common_mistakes": "Do not convert promised work into a success claim. Publish evidence, blockers, no-op reasons, unresolved gaps, and the next accountable review.",
            "related_principle": "Participation / Review / Repair / No-Op",
            "related_lane": "VNWO",
            "related_page": "https://vnwo.com/participation/",
            "version": "3.0.8",
            "last_reviewed_utc": "2026-06-21T02:42:50Z",
            "maturity": "Reviewed",
            "intended_user": "Implementation owner, governance maintainer, or reviewer",
            "related_schema": "https://vnwo.com/schemas/implementation-follow-through-record.schema.json",
            "related_example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/implementation-follow-through-community-rule-change.json",
            "machine_readable_url": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "machine_readable_id": "implementation-follow-through-record",
            "license": "Public observatory guidance; reuse with attribution and without implying certification, legal authority, moral authority, or runtime control.",
            "claim_boundary_note": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance.",
            "common_mistake": "Do not convert promised work into a success claim. Publish evidence, blockers, no-op reasons, unresolved gaps, and the next accountable review.",
            "machine_readable_equivalent": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/implementation-follow-through-community-rule-change.json",
            "claim_boundary": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance."
        },
        {
            "id": "participation-process-comparison",
            "title": "Participation Process Comparison",
            "category": "participation",
            "purpose": "Compare information, consultation, deliberation, co-decision, and delegated or binding authority by decision scope, response duty, and authority without ranking people.",
            "when_to_use": "Use while selecting or explaining the influence level for a bounded decision.",
            "what_it_prevents": "Calling consultation co-governance, assuming more authority is always appropriate, or hiding which decisions remain fixed.",
            "copyable_text": "Process comparison: decision=[text], options=[information/consultation/deliberation/co-decision/delegated], selected_level=[level], open_levers=[list], fixed_constraints=[list], reason=[text], response_duty=[text], correction_or_exit=[text].",
            "editable_variables": [
                "decision",
                "candidate levels",
                "selected level",
                "open levers",
                "fixed constraints",
                "reason",
                "response duty",
                "correction or exit path"
            ],
            "common_mistakes": "Do not rank participants or treat the highest influence level as universally superior. Match authority to the decision, affected people, legal constraints, and review capacity.",
            "related_principle": "Participation / Disclosure / Anti-Overreach",
            "related_lane": "VNWO",
            "related_page": "https://vnwo.com/participation/",
            "version": "3.0.8",
            "last_reviewed_utc": "2026-06-21T02:42:50Z",
            "maturity": "Reviewed",
            "intended_user": "Decision owner or participation process designer",
            "related_schema": "https://vnwo.com/schemas/participation-process-comparison.schema.json",
            "related_example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/participation-process-comparison.json",
            "machine_readable_url": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "machine_readable_id": "participation-process-comparison",
            "license": "Public observatory guidance; reuse with attribution and without implying certification, legal authority, moral authority, or runtime control.",
            "claim_boundary_note": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance.",
            "common_mistake": "Do not rank participants or treat the highest influence level as universally superior. Match authority to the decision, affected people, legal constraints, and review capacity.",
            "machine_readable_equivalent": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/participation-process-comparison.json",
            "claim_boundary": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance."
        },
        {
            "id": "monitoring-without-surveillance-policy",
            "title": "Monitoring Without Surveillance Policy",
            "category": "monitoring",
            "purpose": "Define minimum routine telemetry and a staged, reviewable escalation path.",
            "when_to_use": "Use whenever a network collects operational, security, identity, flow, endpoint, or incident telemetry.",
            "what_it_prevents": "Ambient payload inspection, permanent incident collection, secondary-use drift, and surveillance-by-default.",
            "copyable_text": "Routine monitoring uses the least revealing data sufficient for the stated purpose. Elevated collection requires a case identifier, necessity statement, approving roles, start and end UTC, disposition rule, review path, and appeal or correction path.",
            "editable_variables": [
                "routine telemetry",
                "purpose",
                "escalation trigger",
                "approving roles",
                "expiry",
                "disposition",
                "review path"
            ],
            "common_mistakes": "Do not call collection minimal while retaining identity-linked raw events indefinitely or reusing them for unrelated ranking.",
            "related_principle": "Review / Anti-Overreach",
            "related_lane": "VNWO / ErrorNotifier",
            "related_page": "https://vnwo.com/observability-without-surveillance/",
            "version": "3.0.8",
            "last_reviewed_utc": "2026-06-21T02:42:50Z",
            "maturity": "Recommended",
            "intended_user": "Security, observability, or incident-response lead",
            "related_schema": "https://vnwo.com/schemas/monitoring-escalation.schema.json",
            "related_example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/monitoring-escalation.json",
            "machine_readable_url": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "machine_readable_id": "monitoring-without-surveillance-policy",
            "license": "Public observatory guidance; reuse with attribution and without implying certification, legal authority, moral authority, or runtime control.",
            "claim_boundary_note": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance.",
            "common_mistake": "Do not call collection minimal while retaining identity-linked raw events indefinitely or reusing them for unrelated ranking.",
            "machine_readable_equivalent": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/monitoring-escalation.json",
            "claim_boundary": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance."
        },
        {
            "id": "metadata-minimization-notice",
            "title": "Metadata Minimization Notice",
            "category": "privacy",
            "purpose": "Disclose what metadata is collected, why, how it can be correlated, how long it remains, and what is excluded.",
            "when_to_use": "Use for DNS, destination, timing, flow, identity, location, association, account, endpoint, and memory metadata.",
            "what_it_prevents": "Invisible behavioral inference, cross-context correlation, permanent dossiers, and content-encryption claims that ignore metadata.",
            "copyable_text": "This network collects [metadata type] for [purpose]. It does not collect [excluded data]. It retains [data] for [duration], aggregates [fields] before routine review, and requires [approval path] for escalation. Participants may request [review/export/correction where applicable].",
            "editable_variables": [
                "metadata type",
                "purpose",
                "excluded data",
                "retention",
                "aggregation",
                "approval path",
                "participant rights"
            ],
            "common_mistakes": "Do not describe metadata as anonymous without analyzing linkability, inference, cohort size, and auxiliary-data risk.",
            "related_principle": "Consent / Review / Anti-Overreach",
            "related_lane": "VNWO",
            "related_page": "https://vnwo.com/metadata-is-power/",
            "version": "3.0.8",
            "last_reviewed_utc": "2026-06-21T02:42:50Z",
            "maturity": "Recommended",
            "intended_user": "Privacy engineer or system architect",
            "related_schema": "https://vnwo.com/schemas/metadata-inventory.schema.json",
            "related_example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/metadata-inventory.json",
            "machine_readable_url": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "machine_readable_id": "metadata-minimization-notice",
            "license": "Public observatory guidance; reuse with attribution and without implying certification, legal authority, moral authority, or runtime control.",
            "claim_boundary_note": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance.",
            "common_mistake": "Do not describe metadata as anonymous without analyzing linkability, inference, cohort size, and auxiliary-data risk.",
            "machine_readable_equivalent": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/metadata-inventory.json",
            "claim_boundary": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance."
        },
        {
            "id": "agent-action-receipt",
            "title": "Agent Action Receipt",
            "category": "agent",
            "purpose": "Record the actor, represented party, authority source, bounded action, touched resources, approval threshold, result, and revocation path.",
            "when_to_use": "Use when an AI agent or mixed actor takes or attempts an action that affects data, endpoints, publication, money, identity, or governance.",
            "what_it_prevents": "Hidden delegation, capability-as-permission, silent tool escalation, and actions with no accountable authority source.",
            "copyable_text": "Agent action receipt: actor_label=[label], represented_party=[party], requested_action=[action], authority_source=[source], allowed_scope=[scope], policy_check=[result], endpoint_or_data_touched=[items], human_approval_required=[yes/no], result=[result], timestamp_utc=[UTC], review_path=[path], revocation_path=[path].",
            "editable_variables": [
                "actor label",
                "represented party",
                "action",
                "authority source",
                "scope",
                "policy result",
                "resources",
                "approval",
                "UTC",
                "review",
                "revocation"
            ],
            "common_mistakes": "Do not infer delegated authority from a tool being available, a prior prompt, stale memory, or public capability metadata.",
            "related_principle": "Disclosure / Review",
            "related_lane": "VNWO / Carcinus / LocalEndpoint",
            "related_page": "https://vnwo.com/agentic-ai-governance/",
            "version": "3.0.8",
            "last_reviewed_utc": "2026-06-21T02:42:50Z",
            "maturity": "Recommended",
            "intended_user": "Agent builder or operations reviewer",
            "related_schema": "https://vnwo.com/schemas/agent-authority-envelope.schema.json",
            "related_example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/agent-authority-envelope.json",
            "machine_readable_url": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "machine_readable_id": "agent-action-receipt",
            "license": "Public observatory guidance; reuse with attribution and without implying certification, legal authority, moral authority, or runtime control.",
            "claim_boundary_note": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance.",
            "common_mistake": "Do not infer delegated authority from a tool being available, a prior prompt, stale memory, or public capability metadata.",
            "machine_readable_equivalent": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/agent-authority-envelope.json",
            "claim_boundary": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance."
        },
        {
            "id": "escalation-receipt",
            "title": "Monitoring Escalation Receipt",
            "category": "monitoring",
            "purpose": "Record why a higher-observation monitoring stage is necessary and when it must end.",
            "when_to_use": "Use before targeted packet, payload, identity-linked, or incident-scoped collection exceeds routine telemetry.",
            "what_it_prevents": "Emergency collection becoming permanent, unnamed approval, missing expiry, evidence reuse, and unappealable surveillance.",
            "copyable_text": "Escalation receipt: incident_or_trigger=[trigger], affected_system=[system], requested_collection=[collection], lower_overreach_controls_insufficient_because=[reason], approving_roles=[roles], start_utc=[UTC], end_utc=[UTC], data_disposition=[rule], review_path=[path], appeal_or_correction_path=[path].",
            "editable_variables": [
                "trigger",
                "system",
                "collection",
                "necessity",
                "approvers",
                "start UTC",
                "end UTC",
                "disposition",
                "review",
                "appeal"
            ],
            "common_mistakes": "Do not approve an escalation with no end time, no disposition, or a purpose broad enough to cover unrelated future use.",
            "related_principle": "Review / Repair / Anti-Overreach",
            "related_lane": "VNWO / ErrorNotifier",
            "related_page": "https://vnwo.com/observability-without-surveillance/",
            "version": "3.0.8",
            "last_reviewed_utc": "2026-06-21T02:42:50Z",
            "maturity": "Recommended",
            "intended_user": "Security or observability reviewer",
            "related_schema": "https://vnwo.com/schemas/monitoring-escalation.schema.json",
            "related_example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/monitoring-escalation.json",
            "machine_readable_url": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "machine_readable_id": "escalation-receipt",
            "license": "Public observatory guidance; reuse with attribution and without implying certification, legal authority, moral authority, or runtime control.",
            "claim_boundary_note": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance.",
            "common_mistake": "Do not approve an escalation with no end time, no disposition, or a purpose broad enough to cover unrelated future use.",
            "machine_readable_equivalent": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/monitoring-escalation.json",
            "claim_boundary": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance."
        },
        {
            "id": "repair-request",
            "title": "Repair and Appeal Request",
            "category": "repair",
            "purpose": "Request correction, annotation, rollback, revocation, restored access, archive, or no-op handling for a bounded governance error.",
            "when_to_use": "Use for memory, identity, agent output, moderation, endpoint, monitoring, governance-change, or claim-boundary disputes.",
            "what_it_prevents": "Circular support, hidden appeal queues, retaliation, evidence loss, and corrections that silently rewrite history.",
            "copyable_text": "Repair request: affected_person_or_actor=[actor], affected_record_or_action=[reference], issue_type=[type], evidence=[summary], requested_correction=[remedy], urgency=[level], desired_outcome=[outcome], handling=[public/private], review_path=[path], appeal_path=[path].",
            "editable_variables": [
                "actor",
                "record or action",
                "issue type",
                "evidence",
                "remedy",
                "urgency",
                "outcome",
                "handling",
                "review",
                "appeal"
            ],
            "common_mistakes": "Do not require secret files or unrelated personal data merely to open a repair request.",
            "related_principle": "Repair",
            "related_lane": "VNWO / Neurovanic / ErrorNotifier",
            "related_page": "https://vnwo.com/repair-and-appeals/",
            "version": "3.0.8",
            "last_reviewed_utc": "2026-06-21T02:42:50Z",
            "maturity": "Recommended",
            "intended_user": "Participant, reviewer, or appeals operator",
            "related_schema": "https://vnwo.com/schemas/judgment-appeal.schema.json",
            "related_example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/judgment-appeal.json",
            "machine_readable_url": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "machine_readable_id": "repair-request",
            "license": "Public observatory guidance; reuse with attribution and without implying certification, legal authority, moral authority, or runtime control.",
            "claim_boundary_note": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance.",
            "common_mistake": "Do not require secret files or unrelated personal data merely to open a repair request.",
            "machine_readable_equivalent": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/judgment-appeal.json",
            "claim_boundary": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance."
        },
        {
            "id": "exit-rights-checklist",
            "title": "Exit Rights Checklist",
            "category": "exit",
            "purpose": "Separate export, transfer, deletion, closure, revocation, correction, retention, and forkability into testable exit steps.",
            "when_to_use": "Use during product design, offboarding, account closure, agent disengagement, endpoint revocation, or community departure.",
            "what_it_prevents": "False exit, orphaned permissions, inaccessible continuity, retaliatory deletion, and confusing export with erasure.",
            "copyable_text": "Exit checklist: identity_export=[status], memory_export=[status], evidence_export=[status], endpoint_grants_revoked=[ids], agent_delegations_revoked=[ids], account_closure=[status], retained_records_and_reason=[text], correction_path=[url], forkability_status=[status], completed_utc=[UTC].",
            "editable_variables": [
                "exports",
                "revoked grants",
                "delegations",
                "closure",
                "retention reason",
                "correction",
                "forkability",
                "UTC"
            ],
            "common_mistakes": "Do not mark exit complete while delegated agents, webhooks, tokens, endpoint grants, or active memory remain unexplained.",
            "related_principle": "Exit / Portability",
            "related_lane": "VNWO / UAIX / LocalEndpoint",
            "related_page": "https://vnwo.com/exit-rights/",
            "version": "3.0.8",
            "last_reviewed_utc": "2026-06-21T02:42:50Z",
            "maturity": "Recommended",
            "intended_user": "Participant-support or offboarding owner",
            "related_schema": "https://vnwo.com/schemas/exit-packet.schema.json",
            "related_example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/exit-packet.json",
            "machine_readable_url": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "machine_readable_id": "exit-rights-checklist",
            "license": "Public observatory guidance; reuse with attribution and without implying certification, legal authority, moral authority, or runtime control.",
            "claim_boundary_note": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance.",
            "common_mistake": "Do not mark exit complete while delegated agents, webhooks, tokens, endpoint grants, or active memory remain unexplained.",
            "machine_readable_equivalent": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/exit-packet.json",
            "claim_boundary": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance."
        },
        {
            "id": "cloud-sovereignty-caution",
            "title": "Cloud Sovereignty Caution",
            "category": "architecture",
            "purpose": "Describe provider, key-custody, administrator, jurisdiction, attestation, and exit limits without claiming absolute sovereignty.",
            "when_to_use": "Use in cloud architecture documents, provider reviews, key-management plans, confidential-computing claims, and migration plans.",
            "what_it_prevents": "Data-residency theater, contract-only controls, provider-admin opacity, attestation overclaiming, and untested exit.",
            "copyable_text": "Confidential computing and customer-controlled keys can reduce provider visibility when implemented correctly. This statement does not certify application correctness, eliminate metadata leakage or side channels, guarantee legal compliance, or prove provider independence. Provider access, key custody, administrative roles, attestation scope, retention, and exit remain documented and reviewable.",
            "editable_variables": [
                "provider",
                "key custodian",
                "administrative roles",
                "attestation scope",
                "retention",
                "exit plan"
            ],
            "common_mistakes": "Do not treat data location, encryption, attestation, or a contract as a universal proof of privacy or sovereignty.",
            "related_principle": "Anti-Overreach / Exit",
            "related_lane": "VNWO",
            "related_page": "https://vnwo.com/cloud-sovereignty/",
            "version": "3.0.8",
            "last_reviewed_utc": "2026-06-21T02:42:50Z",
            "maturity": "Experimental",
            "intended_user": "Cloud architect or procurement reviewer",
            "related_schema": "https://vnwo.com/schemas/cloud-sovereignty-profile.schema.json",
            "related_example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/cloud-sovereignty-profile.json",
            "machine_readable_url": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "machine_readable_id": "cloud-sovereignty-caution",
            "license": "Public observatory guidance; reuse with attribution and without implying certification, legal authority, moral authority, or runtime control.",
            "claim_boundary_note": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance.",
            "common_mistake": "Do not treat data location, encryption, attestation, or a contract as a universal proof of privacy or sovereignty.",
            "machine_readable_equivalent": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/cloud-sovereignty-profile.json",
            "claim_boundary": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance."
        },
        {
            "id": "zero-trust-without-overreach-checklist",
            "title": "Zero Trust Without Overreach Checklist",
            "category": "architecture",
            "purpose": "Apply per-request least privilege without turning policy and telemetry services into ambient surveillance or unappealable authority.",
            "when_to_use": "Use when replacing VPN reachability, defining PDP/PEP controls, issuing workload identity, or designing microsegmentation.",
            "what_it_prevents": "Broad subnet access, static role sprawl, long-lived credentials, silent denials, centralized raw telemetry, and emergency access without expiry.",
            "copyable_text": "Zero-trust review: resource=[resource], actor=[actor], requested_action=[action], purpose=[purpose], context=[context], credential_expiry=[UTC], policy_version=[version], decision_reason=[reason], appeal_path=[path], telemetry_fields=[fields], exception_expiry=[UTC], revocation_test=[result].",
            "editable_variables": [
                "resource",
                "actor",
                "action",
                "purpose",
                "context",
                "expiry",
                "policy version",
                "reason",
                "appeal",
                "telemetry",
                "exception",
                "revocation"
            ],
            "common_mistakes": "Do not replace broad network trust with a central policy system that silently collects everything and offers no reason or appeal.",
            "related_principle": "Consent / Review / Anti-Overreach",
            "related_lane": "VNWO / LocalEndpoint",
            "related_page": "https://vnwo.com/zero-trust-without-overreach/",
            "version": "3.0.8",
            "last_reviewed_utc": "2026-06-21T02:42:50Z",
            "maturity": "Experimental",
            "intended_user": "Security architect or endpoint owner",
            "related_schema": "https://vnwo.com/schemas/technical-architecture-profile.schema.json",
            "related_example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/contractor-application-access-case.json",
            "machine_readable_url": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "machine_readable_id": "zero-trust-without-overreach-checklist",
            "license": "Public observatory guidance; reuse with attribution and without implying certification, legal authority, moral authority, or runtime control.",
            "claim_boundary_note": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance.",
            "common_mistake": "Do not replace broad network trust with a central policy system that silently collects everything and offers no reason or appeal.",
            "machine_readable_equivalent": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/contractor-application-access-case.json",
            "claim_boundary": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance."
        },
        {
            "id": "claim-boundary-statement",
            "title": "Claim Boundary Statement",
            "category": "claim-boundary",
            "purpose": "Prevent overclaiming by stating what the network does and does not claim.",
            "when_to_use": "Use on public pages, docs, agent-readable files, governance notices, and templates.",
            "what_it_prevents": "Safety certification claims, legal authority claims, consciousness claims, final AI judgment claims, and ecosystem lane conflicts.",
            "copyable_text": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance for open rules across virtual networks. It does not certify safety, grant legal status, execute agents, import files, sync memory, validate credentials, or override another ecosystem lane.",
            "editable_variables": [
                "site name",
                "implementation lane",
                "related tool",
                "last reviewed UTC"
            ],
            "common_mistakes": "Keep scope explicit and do not overclaim.",
            "related_principle": "Anti-Overreach",
            "related_lane": "VNWO / Teleodynamic",
            "related_page": "https://vnwo.com/claim-boundaries/",
            "version": "3.0.8",
            "last_reviewed_utc": "2026-06-21T02:42:50Z",
            "maturity": "Recommended",
            "intended_user": "Editor, maintainer, or implementation reviewer",
            "related_schema": "https://vnwo.com/schemas/claim-boundary.schema.json",
            "related_example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/claim-boundary-lint-rules.json",
            "machine_readable_url": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "machine_readable_id": "claim-boundary-statement",
            "license": "Public observatory guidance; reuse with attribution and without implying certification, legal authority, moral authority, or runtime control.",
            "claim_boundary_note": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance.",
            "common_mistake": "Keep scope explicit and do not overclaim.",
            "machine_readable_equivalent": "https://vnwo.com/open-rules.json",
            "example": "https://vnwo.com/examples/claim-boundary-lint-rules.json",
            "claim_boundary": "VNWO publishes static public observatory guidance and templates. It does not certify safety or viability, provide legal advice, run agents, import files, monitor private systems, authorize endpoints, or guarantee compliance."
        }
    ],
    "formal_artifacts": []
}