{
  "schema_version": "3.0.8",
  "id": "participation-strategic-exit-001",
  "version": "3.0.8",
  "last_reviewed_utc": "2026-06-20T17:20:17Z",
  "artifact_maturity": "reference",
  "process_title": "Fictional coordinated refusal and fork over an undisclosed memory-policy expansion",
  "decision_scope": "The operator could withdraw the proposed memory expansion, publish a narrower consent rule, or accept a peaceful community fork with scoped export and non-retaliation.",
  "decision_owner": "Example Network governance board",
  "participation_level": "consultation",
  "affected_groups": [
    "community participants",
    "memory stewards",
    "delegated agent operators"
  ],
  "participant_scope_and_gaps": "A coalition submitted a public refusal notice and fork condition. The example does not claim every participant joined or agreed.",
  "non_negotiable_constraints": [
    "No transfer of private memory without consent",
    "No retaliation against people who refuse the new policy",
    "No claim that public metadata authorizes memory access"
  ],
  "contribution_channels": [
    {
      "channel": "Public coalition notice plus private correction channel",
      "access_supports": [
        "plain-text notice",
        "pseudonymous endorsement option",
        "offline export request"
      ],
      "privacy_posture": "Public names were optional; private account and memory details were excluded.",
      "compensation_or_cost_support": "No compensation; the coalition documented migration burden as part of the remedy request."
    }
  ],
  "contributions": [
    {
      "contribution_id": "SE-001",
      "participant_group": "participant coalition",
      "summary": "Refuse the new memory scope unless explicit renewed consent and per-class export are provided.",
      "evidence_references": [
        "fictional-policy-diff",
        "fictional-memory-impact-note"
      ],
      "dissent_or_minority_report": false,
      "disposition": "partially_accepted",
      "disposition_reason": "The operator withdrew automatic activation and added renewed consent, but retained an optional feature.",
      "resulting_change": "The feature is opt-in, class-scoped, exportable, and revocable.",
      "response_owner": "Governance board"
    },
    {
      "contribution_id": "SE-002",
      "participant_group": "fork working group",
      "summary": "Publish a scoped export and non-retaliation path if the policy remains available.",
      "evidence_references": [
        "fictional-fork-plan"
      ],
      "dissent_or_minority_report": false,
      "disposition": "accepted",
      "disposition_reason": "Forkability and exit were already declared principles and the request reduced capture risk.",
      "resulting_change": "A fork packet, export window, and correction notice were published.",
      "response_owner": "Records steward"
    },
    {
      "contribution_id": "SE-003",
      "participant_group": "minority report",
      "summary": "Retire the feature entirely rather than retain an opt-in form.",
      "evidence_references": [],
      "dissent_or_minority_report": true,
      "disposition": "rejected",
      "disposition_reason": "The board retained the bounded opt-in feature but preserved the objection and scheduled review after the first implementation cycle.",
      "resulting_change": "No retirement; future review trigger and minority report added.",
      "response_owner": "Governance board"
    }
  ],
  "dissent_and_minority_reports": [
    "A minority position requested complete retirement of the memory expansion."
  ],
  "changes_made": [
    "Automatic activation withdrawn",
    "Renewed consent required",
    "Per-class export and revocation added",
    "Peaceful fork and non-retaliation path published"
  ],
  "changes_not_made": [
    "The optional memory feature was not retired entirely."
  ],
  "public_response_commitment": "The governance board publishes dispositions and a policy diff before the effective date.",
  "correction_or_appeal_path": "Participants may correct the coalition summary, challenge an export omission, or appeal retaliatory treatment.",
  "non_retaliation_statement": "Refusal, boycott, fork preparation, or exit does not reduce reputation, export scope, or correction rights.",
  "data_use_and_retention": "Only the public coalition notice, dispositions, policy diff, and non-identifying fork record are retained in this fictional example.",
  "withdrawal_refusal_or_exit_path": "Participants may refuse the feature, revoke consent, export scoped records, disengage agents, join the fork, or close participation.",
  "next_review_utc": "2026-12-19T18:28:16Z",
  "public_summary_url": "https://vnwo.com/participation/",
  "source_domain": "vnwo.com",
  "claim_boundary_note": "Fictional static example. It does not certify collective representation, labor status, legal sufficiency, consent validity, or actual implementation behavior."
}