{
  "schema_version": "3.0.8",
  "id": "decision-change-community-rule-change-001",
  "version": "3.0.8",
  "last_reviewed_utc": "2026-06-20T17:20:17Z",
  "artifact_maturity": "reference",
  "process_id": "participation-readiness-community-rule-change-001",
  "process_title": "Fictional review of an AI-assisted community rule change",
  "decision_scope": "Disclosure wording, temporary-action duration, human-review triggers, appeal timing, and effective date.",
  "influence_level": "co_decision",
  "decision_owner": "Example Community governance working group",
  "proposal_before_participation": {
    "proposal_version": "draft-0.8",
    "summary": "Permit an automated visibility limit for up to 24 hours, require human review only for permanent removal, and provide an appeal link on the policy page.",
    "open_levers": [
      "temporary-action duration",
      "human-review trigger",
      "appeal response window",
      "notice wording",
      "effective date"
    ],
    "fixed_constraints": [
      "No automated permanent removal",
      "No publication of private case records",
      "No inference that silence equals approval"
    ],
    "evidence_references": [
      "fictional-policy-draft-0.8",
      "participation-readiness-community-rule-change-001"
    ]
  },
  "final_decision": {
    "decision_summary": "Limit automated visibility actions to six hours, require a reason code and evidence reference, require named human renewal, place the appeal link in every consequential notice, and delay the effective date for accessibility repair.",
    "decision_utc": "2026-06-19T20:30:00Z",
    "effective_utc": "2026-07-15T00:00:00Z",
    "decision_authority": "Example Community governance working group within the published co-decision scope",
    "public_record_url": "https://vnwo.com/examples/decision-change-community-rule-change.json"
  },
  "adopted_requests": [
    {
      "contribution_id": "C-001",
      "request_summary": "Require human approval for permanent removal and show the appeal route in every consequential notice.",
      "adoption_status": "accepted",
      "resulting_change": "Human approval remains mandatory and every consequential notice now links directly to appeal.",
      "evidence_references": [
        "contribution-disposition-public-comment",
        "fictional-session-notes-01"
      ]
    },
    {
      "contribution_id": "C-002",
      "request_summary": "Allow a temporary automated action but reduce its duration and require review.",
      "adoption_status": "partially_accepted",
      "resulting_change": "The duration changed from 24 hours to six hours and renewal requires a named human reviewer.",
      "evidence_references": [
        "contribution-disposition-red-team-review"
      ]
    },
    {
      "contribution_id": "C-003",
      "request_summary": "Use plain-language notices and a non-visual status indicator.",
      "adoption_status": "accepted",
      "resulting_change": "Notice copy and status markup were revised before the effective date.",
      "evidence_references": [
        "fictional-accessibility-review"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "non_adopted_requests": [
    {
      "contribution_id": "C-004",
      "request_summary": "Prohibit every automated visibility limit.",
      "disposition": "rejected",
      "reason": "The final decision retains a narrowly scoped six-hour action for immediate exposure of personal contact information, with named human renewal and appeal.",
      "future_review_trigger": "Reopen if the action produces an unresolved accessibility or false-positive pattern."
    },
    {
      "contribution_id": "C-005",
      "request_summary": "Guarantee that every appeal will be resolved within one hour.",
      "disposition": "no_op",
      "reason": "The organization lacks staffing evidence to make that guarantee and will not publish an unsupported service commitment.",
      "future_review_trigger": "Review after three months of measured queue capacity without participant surveillance."
    }
  ],
  "dissent_retained": [
    {
      "dissent_id": "D-001",
      "summary": "A minority position opposes all automated visibility limits.",
      "unresolved_risk": "Even temporary automated restriction may suppress lawful expression before a human sees the case.",
      "publication_url": "https://vnwo.com/examples/minority-dissent-red-team-report.json"
    }
  ],
  "change_summary": [
    "Temporary action maximum reduced from 24 hours to six hours.",
    "Reason code, evidence reference, and named human renewal added.",
    "Appeal route moved into every consequential notice.",
    "Effective date delayed for accessibility repair."
  ],
  "unchanged_elements": [
    "No automated permanent removal.",
    "No publication of private case records.",
    "A narrowly scoped temporary automated action remains available."
  ],
  "implementation_owner": "Example Community policy and interface maintainers",
  "target_implementation_utc": "2026-07-10T23:59:59Z",
  "actual_implementation_status": "in_progress",
  "implementation_evidence_references": [
    "https://vnwo.com/examples/implementation-follow-through-community-rule-change.json"
  ],
  "correction_history": [
    {
      "correction_id": "COR-001",
      "requested_utc": "2026-06-19T20:45:00Z",
      "issue": "The first summary incorrectly described the process as binding authority beyond the five open levers.",
      "disposition": "accepted",
      "record_change": "The summary now states co-decision only within the published scope."
    }
  ],
  "exit_impact": {
    "affected": true,
    "summary": "Participants retain account closure, export, correction, and peaceful fork paths; the rule change does not narrow them.",
    "export_revocation_or_fork_path": "https://vnwo.com/exit-rights/"
  },
  "source_domain": "vnwo.com",
  "claim_boundary_note": "Fictional static example. It documents a change trace but does not prove participation quality, consent, fairness, democratic legitimacy, legal sufficiency, or actual deployment."
}